It’s Tricky: Understanding Allocability, Part I
Of the cost principles outlined in Uniform Guidance (allowable, allocable, reasonable, and consistently treated), allocability can be one of the trickiest and most time-consuming to determine.
Why? Allocability requires us to consider the relative benefit received by a Federal award. In other words, we need to determine whether the award received a benefit from the cost and, if so, how much of that cost should appropriately be assigned to the award.
Did you know?
The Federal Cost Principles are applied to all awards at CSU regardless of sponsor (e.g., Federal, State, Industry, Foundation, etc.) And regardless of funding mechanism (e.g., grant, contract, cooperative agreement, and other).
Under Uniform Guidance, a cost is allocable to an award when it meets one of the following criteria:
- The expense is incurred solely for the award.
- The expense benefits both the award and other work and can be distributed between them in proportions that may be approximated using reasonable methods.
- The expense is necessary to the overall operation of the institution and is assignable in part to the award in accordance with the relative benefits received.
Let’s look at a couple of examples to see how this works in practice.
Example 1: A Computer and an Extended Warranty
A researcher is hired to work on a project in year 2 of a 3-year project (Project A). You purchase a $2,000 computer for the researcher. The computer also comes with an optional 3-year extended warranty for $200.
How should the $2,200 expense be allocated?
- The $2,000 Computer.
Assuming the computer meets CSU’s definition of a supply based on its cost and other applicable criteria, and assuming supplies are allowable under the award, the $2,000 computer is being used solely to support the researcher working on the project.
Therefore, the entire $2,000 cost can be allocated to the award.
- The $200 Extended Warranty
The extended warranty is a little different.
The warranty provides a benefit for 3 years, but the project has only 2 years remaining. Because the benefit to the award extends beyond the project’s end date, the entire $200 warranty cannot be allocated to the award.
If the warranty is purchased with 2 full years remaining on the project, two-thirds of the warranty cost can be allocated to the project:
- Sponsored award: $200 × 2/3 = $133.33
- Non-sponsored account: $200 × 1/3 = $66.67
Total allocated to the award: $2,133.33
Notice that the dollar amount of the warranty is relatively small. That doesn’t mean allocability can be overlooked. Every cost must be evaluated based on the benefit it provides to the award.
Extended warranties, service contracts, maintenance agreements, and similar costs can require a different allocability analysis than the underlying item they support.
Example 2: The Researcher Works on Two Projects
Now let’s change the scenario.
The researcher works on two different projects:
- Sponsored Project A: 30% of the researcher’s effort
- Sponsored Project B: 70% of the researcher’s effort
Project A, from Example 1 above, has 2 years remaining. Project B is a 5-year project that has just begun.
How should the computer and extended warranty be allocated?
- Project A
The computer is allocated based on the researcher’s effort:
- Computer: $2,000 × 30% = $600
- The warranty is also allocated based on the relative benefit to Project A. Because Project A has 2 years remaining out of the 3-year warranty period:
- Warranty: $200 × 30% × 2/3 = $40
Total for Project A: $640
- Project B
The computer is allocated based on the researcher’s effort:
- Computer: $2,000 × 70% = $1,400
- Because Project B has just begun and will continue for 5 years, the entire 3-year warranty period falls within the period of performance. Therefore, the full portion of the warranty attributable to Project B can be allocated to the project:
- Warranty: $200 × 70% = $140
Total to Project B: $1,540
What About the Remaining Cost?
The remaining $20 of the warranty is allocated to a non-sponsored project account.
So, the final allocation of the $2,200 purchase is:
- Sponsored Project A: $640
- Sponsored Project B: $1,540
- Non-sponsored account: $20
- Total: $2,200
The key point is that the cost wasn’t simply split between the projects based on the researcher’s effort. The timing and period of benefit of the warranty also had to be considered.
Written by Shannon Irey, Training and Information Coordinator, OSP. ChatGPT was used to improve tone, readability, and clarity.